Copy

Hello,

I am excited to share our Fall Newsletter with you. 

One of our core aims at the Migration Policy Centre is to advance academic research and knowledge on the transnational governance of migration, asylum and mobility. A key part of that is making sure you hear about it. 

To help, we've summarised it all. We've pulled out key objectives and findings, hopefully in a way that gives you a sense of its importance and piques
 your interest to read more. I hope you'll explore below.

If you like it, would you share it over on
LinkedIn or X (formerly Twitter)?

Best, 

Andrew Geddes

Professor of Migration Studies and Director of the Migration Policy Centre

Migration Policy Centre
Fall Newsletter 
Announcements
 

We're hiring a Research Fellow to join our new project 'Innovating to Enhance Dialogues on Migration Policies and Practices'. Application deadline: 30 November 2023


A Call for Papers is out for our conference with the Global Citizenship Observatory: 'An interconnected world? Rethinking citizenship and migration.' Deadline for paper proposals: 30 November 2023


The Migration Working Group has two upcoming seminars: Differential migrant inclusion on Wednesday 22 November from 15:00 - 16:30 CET and Claiming rights as migrant and addressing refugees’ needs, on Thursday 14 December from 10:30 - 12:00 CET. 

Research

Mobility processes and practices


How migrant resource centres affect migration decisions: quasi‐experimental evidence from Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Iraq and Pakistan 
by James Dennison
This presents quasi-experimental evidence of the effects of Migrant Resource Centres (MRCs) on migration behaviour across six cities in Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Iraq and Pakistan.
  • MRCs have noticeable effects; there is evidence of a large reduction in individuals reporting the likelihood of migrating irregularly and a strong increase in individuals’ awareness of safe options and who to contact for assistance if they do migrate.
  • The effects are consistent across different MRC locations and the types of services they provide, although magnitudes vary.
  • These findings have implications for understanding how individuals decide to migrate and what interventions could effectively inform those decisions.

Markets of displacement
by Luigi Achilli and Kim Wilson
This chapter examines the financial dynamics of migrant smuggling, highlighting migrants’ struggles with funding, and how these influence their journeys. 
  • Shrinking legal migration pathways significantly impact migrants in the Eastern Mediterranean and Central America and increase reliance on exploitative systems.
  • In transit cities like Tijuana and Izmir, migrants live in a liminal state, which leads to both exploitation and agency, often marked by engagement in illicit activities.
  • The complex realities of migration blur traditional distinctions, such as victim/exploiter and refugee/migrant, underscoring the limitations of current border-control policies and categorizations.

The reliability of recall measurement in assessing migrant reintegration: Evidence from Ethiopia, Somalia, and Sudan 
by James Dennison
This study analyses data from the 'IMPACT' evaluation on the EU-IOM Joint Initiative to reintegrate 
1774 East African migrant returnees. It looks at how reliable the use of retrospective or ‘recall’ measurement is to estimate baseline values in impact assessments. 
  • Retrospective measurement is a form of collecting data about past events from participants by asking them to remember and report on those events after they have occurred.
  • More than half of participants in the evaluation were scored on reintegration measures retrospectively. Returnees who were measured retrospectively gave more negative scores on several indicators of successful reintegration. 
  • However, this— mostly non-statistically significant— effect is largely diminished when the small minority who report finding it difficult to remember the baseline period are removed. Suggestions are provided of how to use retrospective measurement. 

Public Attitudes to Migration 


Blame it on my youth: the origins of attitudes towards immigration 

by Anne-Marie Jeannet  and Lenka Dražanová
The article delves into generational differences in attitudes towards immigration in Western European countries.
  • even subtle shifts in national politics can impact political orientations
  • exposure to the principle of equality in the political climate during formative years positively affects immigration attitudes in adulthood even long after
  • the interplay between attitudes and political context during formative years is important 

Communication on irregular migration 
by James Dennison
This report identifies how to achieve significant positive change in how communication on irregular migration is received by using values, emotions, narratives, and impact assessments:
  • To be more effective, communication on irregular migration should go beyond raising awareness or emphasizing security reasons, adopting a broader approach based on core values.
  • Effective communication needs to tell stories that include facts and come from trusted sources. 
  • Communicators need to check how well messages work right from the beginning to avoid any unexpected problems.

Which individual-level factors explain public attitudes toward immigration? : A meta-analysis 
by Lenka Dražanová, Jérome Gonnot, Tobias Heidland, and  Finja Krueger
This article describes a meta-analysis that was conducted to see what individual-level characteristics are most significantly associated with attitudes to immigration.
  • mainly two factors are associated with attitudes to immigration: education (positively) and age (negatively)
  • if an analysis lacks certain variables, part of their effect might be wrongly attributed to other explanatory variables
  • economic factors are consistently less important than cultural factors in affecting attitudes to immigration

Basic human values and preferences for an EU-Wide social benefit scheme
by Ann-Kathrin Reinl, Daniel Seddig, James Dennison, and Eldad Davidov
This article tests how basic human values directly influence how much people in the EU support social benefits across the EU.
  • Previous findings of the effects of values on attitudes to immigration and EU membership can be expanded to other policy areas, such as support for EU-wide benefits.
  • Values of security and universalism have a small direct effect on whether people support EU-wide benefits. They have an indirect effect on how individuals self-identify politically, support for European integration and European identity.
  • Individuals from countries who countribute more to the EU budget demonstrate higher levels of universalism and higher levels of support for EU-wide benefits.

Emotions: functions and significance for attitudes, behaviour and communication 
by James Dennison
This article explores how emotions play a crucial role in effective communication strategies, particularly in the context of migration, providing guidance on choosing emotional frames to elicit desired physiological and behavioral reactions.
  • Using a conceptual framework developed by Robert Plutchik, 32 emotions are identified along with their theorised physiological reactions, possible stimuli, and behavioural societal effects.
  • Emotional outcomes can be altered through different communication techniques, which can include storytelling, personal-based messages, facial expressions and body language, and aesthetics.
  • Emotion-based communication in the field of migration, although widely used, is largely untested.

Labour Markets and Welfare States 


Free movement vs. European welfare states? Variations of the fiscal effects of EU migrants across welfare state regimes 
by Marcus Österman, Joakim Palme, and Martin Ruhs 
This article investigates the fiscal effects of EU migrants (“mobile EU citizens”) across different types of welfare state regimes in Europe. 
  • The empirical analysis covering 29 countries between 2004-2015 reveals positive net fiscal impacts of EU migrants in Western European countries.
  • Further, the study finds no major differences in the fiscal impacts of EU migrants across different welfare regimes in Western European countries 
  • These findings challenge the common claim that advanced welfare states are incompatible with large-scale immigration because of adverse fiscal effects, and they also cast doubt on the idea that broad institutional characteristics of welfare states have substantial consequences for the fiscal impact of migration.

Free movement and European welfare states: Why child benefits for EU workers should not be exportable 
by Martin Ruhs and Joakim Palme
The paper discusses the institutional sources of political conflicts about mobile EU workers’ access to child benefits in the European Union.
  • Current EU regulations allow EU workers (i.e. mobile EU citizens who live and work in a Member State where they do not hold national citizenship) to “export” family benefits for their children and other family members resident in the home country.
  • There is a fundamental tension between the 'employment-based' logic governing EU workers' access to benefits and the 'residence-based' logic underlying family policy in Member States, which contributes to political conflicts between and within EU Member States . 
  • To reduce this tension, the paper makes the case for changing the principles for coordinating EU workers’ access to welfare benefits: It is the country where the child lives, rather than the country where the working parent/spouse is employed, that should bear the responsibility for providing child benefits.
 Blogs and Articles
What do trade agreements have to do with migration policy? 
by Sandra Lavenex, Paula Hoffmeyer-Zlotnik and Philipp Lutz 
Preferential trade agreements (PTAs) aim to facilitate trade between two or more countries. New research from the University of Geneva shows that that more than 70% of all PTAs signed in the last decade also contain provisions on international migration. The majority of these provisions are legally binding commitments that liberalise economic migration, but they can also be used to protect migrant rights and/or fight irregular migration.
International law or national identity? How the German and Polish governments framed whether to accept Syrian and Ukrainian refugees 
by Daniel Drewski and Jürgen Gerhards 
While Germany currently hosts the largest number of both Syrian and Ukrainian refugees in the EU, Poland hosts the second largest number of Ukrainian refugees but refused to take in Syrian refugees. Their different responses make Germany and Poland excellent cases to study how countries differentiate between refugee groups of different origins.
Why liberal refugee policies need enemies 
by Oliviero Angeli
Europe’s extraordinary openness to Ukrainian refugees illustrated, in the eyes of many, how unequal the treatment of different asylum seekers is. Migrant organisations regarded it as a betrayal of the universalist promise of refugee law: that all those in need of protection are to be treated equally. Yet, strictly speaking, the modern refugee regime has never explicitly articulated such a promise, let alone delivered on it.
There’s still strong support for Ukrainian refugees across Europe: new evidence from eight countries 
by Lenka Dražanová and Andrew Geddes
New research from the Migration Policy Centre shows continued high levels of public support in eight European countries for refugees from Ukraine since the full-scale Russian invasion. Europeans remain strongly supportive of Ukrainian refugees with little sign so far of ‘compassion fatigue’ setting in, at least so far as Ukrainian refugees are concerned. The picture is different for refugees from other parts of the world.
Why Canada is Facing an Exodus of Skilled Migrants 
by Marshia Akbar 
A recent study reveals that more than one-fifth of recent immigrants to Canada are contemplating leaving the country. This phenomenon is particularly pronounced among immigrants under the age of 34, with a notable 30 percent expressing a strong likelihood of departing from Canada within the next two years. Losing skilled and talented migrants has concerning potential ramifications on Canada’s economic growth, demographic balance, and social support system.  
How female migrants use entrepreneurship to create meaningful places of connection: A look at Ukrainian women in Poland 
by Kseniya Homel
New research shows that female migrants are using entrepreneurship to challenge ethnic and gender discrimination. Focusing on the beauty sectors in Poland and through qualitative interviews with Ukrainian female migrant entrepreneurs, this research identified patterns that impact their business strategies and what their business activity means to them.
The role of cities in shaping immigrant rights: the case of Houston, Texas
by Els de Graauw 
Scholars have long argued that national laws most strongly affect immigrant rights, but recent research questions if that is still the case. While cities have made significant headway in immigrant rights, most of them are superdiverse gateway cities. But what do immigrant rights struggles look like in cities with less hospitable contexts of reception, such as Houston, Texas?
The constrained displacement of asylum-seekers in France: how emergency became a long-lasting policy 
by Maxime Christophe
During the 2015 “refugee crisis” in Europe, temporary transit centres emerged in France as a tool to prevent urban street camps. Seven years later, transit centres, intended as temporary emergency humanitarian structures, still exist. In fact, they also have become an institutionalised cornerstone of France’s migration policy and shelter system.
The worsening predicament for LGBTQ+ people in Uganda: how a new law could increase displacement 
by A Luta Continua 
Under a new Anti-Homosexuality Law in Uganda, individuals who identify as LGBTQ+ could be sentenced to life in prison. This law is expected to likely increase the number of individuals fleeing to neighbouring countries to seek protection.How did this law get passed? What are the risks for the LGBTQ+ community? How will it impact displacement? This post will answer these questions on this emerging human rights issue.
Gaza conflict: how children’s lives are affected on every level 
by Caitlin Procter, Mohammed al Rozzi, and Jason Hart
Based on our research on humanitarian protection and neglect of refugee children in Gaza, this article argues that the risks facing their health and wellbeing have grown exponentially over the last 16 years as a direct result of the conditions of the Israeli blockade. Refugee children in Gaza have faced six direct military attacks from Israel in their short lifetimes (2008-9, 2012, 2014, 2021, 2022, 2023). Each of these wars has created long-term threats to the survival and wellbeing of refugee children in Gaza. 
 PAST EVENTS

In case you missed it: 


Refugee protection and solidarity: the duties of EU member states | 6 November 2023
Borders to bridges: unlocking Africa for Africans! | 25 October 2023
Pathways to permanence and immigration levels: limits to societal membership for migrants in Canada | 4 October 2023 
NOTEWORTHY

 

The Rama-Meloni Deal:  Is the Italy-Albania agreement on processing asylum claims ethical? |  Lorenzo Piccoli speaks to Euronews Albania | 18 November 2023
Academic research and the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict | Caitlin Protcter presents at a seminar hosted by the Geneva Graduate Institute in partnership with the Institut des Cultures Arabes et Méditerranées on the role and relevance of academic research on Palestine and Israel in the context of the situation unfolding in Gaza. | 18 October 2023
European Council, the themes and votes | Ettore Recchi speaks on Giampoalo Musumeci's No Place is Far Away Radio24 show. | 30 June 2023
LinkedIn
Twitter
Facebook
YouTube
Website
Email

If you are no longer interested in receiving these newsletters, please unsubscribe.